Cafe Amici

Stopped by here with my friend for breakfast just as they opened at 10. We were the first customers so safe to say it was not busy or difficult to get a table (it was also a Tuesday). For being called a Cafe I felt like they didn't have a lot of breakfast options or drinks besides coffee based ones (there was no matcha) and now that I think about it, tea wasn't offered to us either. I ordered the Avocado Toast. I thought it was good! I subbed out the bacon for feta which I felt actually elevated the meal. The service was good because it was slow. The waitress called the owner to get some answers to a few of our questions since she didn't know.

Came here for brunch and got the amici burger. I ordered medium and got medium well, which was great because I prefer medium well. So I would advise ordering 1 notch rarer than what you want. The burger was juicy, but I wished there was more flavor (salt). I kept adding ketchup and black pepper to add some flavor. The server was very nice and service is relatively quick. We just walked in and were seated immediately on a weekend lunch, so reservations are not necessary

I have waited far too long to check this place out. It is a beautiful little Italian spot in Wyckoff and I can see why people regard it so highly. I am was very impressed with the quality of the food and I loved how relaxed our server was. We didn't feel rushed at all, but we were taken care of the whole time. It is BYOB so we brought some of our wine from home which helped keep the price more reasonable. Most of their entrees are around $30, but even the more expensive items were below $50. They have a pretty big dessert menu and the tiramisu was tasty, but the star of the show for me was the Peanut Butter Cup Pie Crust Ice Cream. One of my favorite ice cream flavors that I have every had and I would go back just for that. I also thought the bread they brought to the table was amazing and I scraped every last drop of vodka sauce off my wife's plate because it was so good. I got the burger which was delicious with blue cheese and comes with French fries. They are the thin cut kind and they were yummy.

Cafe Amici is truly a place for friends, family to meet up and have amazing meal in a nice casual environment. All of the food coming out of the kitchen was amazing…the special Ribeye, the Scallops and even the gluten-free pasta was delicious! This is a BYOB spot but located around the corner from a decent liquor / ween store. Enjoy and welcome go to the family….

I take out a lot. The food is good, but the prices keep going up and up. During covid a cheeseburger and a box full of fries was $14. I ordered a cheeseburger last night and was shocked to see their prices went up again. A cheeseburger and a small portion of fries is now $22 with tax. That's an increase of $6. I know things got expensive, but don't take advantage every few months and raise the prices. I will think next time if I order again from Amici.